Session 6.2
Young minds in Geopolitics and International Relations
Chair: Dr Praveen Kumar
Vasu Sharma
A Study of the US Alliance Network 2011-2021: A Theoretical Analysis
The US Alliance Network has been the most enduring and the most formidable alliance system post 1945. Often referred to as the Hubs and Spokes system, the alliance network involved several bilateral alliances with the US as the hub and allies as the spoke. For seven decades, the security environment of the Asia-Pacific has changed with emerging discourses over Indo-Pacific. The shifting nomenclature Asia Pacific to Indo-Pacific and its utilisation in contemporary times dates back to 2011 when Hillary Clinton used the term in context of the US ‘Pivot to Asia’ strategy. The nature of engagement that the US had with its allies in this region changed since 2011. The whole decade from 2011 to 2021 was not only crucial for the US and its allies but all the stakeholders of the Indo-Pacific. With the emerging security architecture of this region becoming much more complex in nature with numerous alliances and partnerships being forged, it becomes necessary to explore the theoretical dimensions of the US Alliance Network in the Indo-Pacific from 2011 to 2021 and analyse the dominant arguments for the same. Under this context the paper discusses the evolution of the US Alliance network in Asia-Pacific, to provide theoretical analysis towards the changing nature of US Alliance System since 2011 to 2021, and to critically assess the current dynamics and arguments of US Alliance System in Indo-Pacific.
Induja J S and Kiran Kumar Bhatt
India's Role in Disaster Management in the Indo-Pacific
In recent years, the frequency and intensity of disasters have increased manifold owing to disruptions in the climate. The Indo Pacific is one of the world’s most disaster-prone regions in this regard where disasters such as tsunamis, earthquakes, flooding, volcanic eruptions and cyclones are common. With every country in the region taking up initiatives at the institutional level, bilateral and multilateral collaborations with other countries and international organizations also become crucial for efficient disaster management. India is an emerging power and prominent player in the Indo-Pacific. With the intention of being a net security provider in the region, India is actively pursuing disaster management initiatives. The country also has huge potential and capabilities to realize its intent to be a first responder in the region. India carries forward bilateral and multilateral relations with countries and international platforms to bring about effective and successful disaster management operations. In the post-pandemic world, disaster management with a special focus on the role and potential of India in the Indo Pacific becomes significant making the study relevant in the contemporary scenario
Shishu Raj
Military Balance across the Taiwan Strait: Implications for the Indo-Pacific
The retreat of United States from Afghanistan and its inability to admit Ukraine in NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization) for which Kyiv is facing one of the largest invasions in Europe since World War –II may boost the Chinese narrative regarding Washington’s inability to honor its commitment or selectively donning the role of global policemen. At the same time, the Russo- Ukraine war has brought the focus back to conventional military conflict and non-nuclear states need to sport a sufficiently capable defense force for insuring its very survival in international life. The official policy of the United States government is that the Republic of China (ROC) or Taiwan, “our long-time ally in the Pacific, be assured 'a sufficient self-defense capability’” (Taiwan Relations Act, Sec. 3a). And Washington has obliged to its policy in true letter and spirit, providing Taipei with some of the best military hardware and continued to assure Taiwan of providing sufficient self-defense capability. However, only an assessment of evolving military balance in the Taiwan Strait can provide a clear picture about the capabilities of ROC in defending against Beijing's invasion. The evolutionary history of life is studied through the aid of two models, namely Gradualism and Punctuated Equilibrium Model. The latter explains that evolution of certain species did not happen in gradual manner but as spurt of huge and slight changes rather than incremental in the case of gradualism. In an article titled “Explaining Change and Stability in Cross-Strait Relations: A Punctuated Equilibrium Model,” the author theorizes the cross-strait relation as cyclical pattern of change and stability. The research is an endeavor to understand the military balance in Taiwan Strait with the aid of punctuated equilibrium model through three broad objectives; (a)To map the cross-strait relations since 2012- 2021 with aide of punctuated equilibrium model; (b) To access the military capabilities of ROC and PRC based on the conflict scenario of Taiwan Strait;(c) To assess the evolution of military balance in Taiwan Strait through the lens of Punctuated Equilibrium Model;(d) To discern the impact of evolving military balance on the security architecture of the Indo-Pacific region.
Mayank Dalvi
Japanese Public Diplomacy in the Indo-Pacific
Over the last few decades, the field of Public Diplomacy is one way through which countries have been trying to assert their influence on others, by generally incorporating elements such as culture and traditions. Today, Japan is seen as one of the foremost practitioners of Public Diplomacy. As a major power in the Indo Pacific, Tokyo has sought to establish its influence in the region since the end of WWII through soft power initiatives. Specifically, Japan’s Public Diplomacy efforts have revolved around promoting aspects of its economy and culture. This study largely adopts Nicholas J. Cull’s understanding of Public Diplomacy, which recognises it as comprising of five elements: listening, advocacy, cultural diplomacy, exchange diplomacy and international broadcasting. Japan has utilised these five elements to varying degrees to engage with countries throughout the Indo-Pacific to successfully promote the view of itself as a technology and cultural hub. The success of this vision has allowed Tokyo to sway regional public opinion in its favour, thereby contributing to its ability to promote initiatives such as Free and Open Indo-Pacific.
Madhu Vanthi
The Emerging Discourse on Extended Deterrence in the Indo-Pacific Theatre
One of the key policies of the United States during the Cold War was the Extended Deterrence, which aimed to protect its allies from the Soviet Union’s attack by threatening a nuclear response. In the past two decades, the security environment in the Indo-Pacific has remained volatile due to various factors including the emergence of the Indo-Pacific as a construct in 2007, China’s aggressive rise, the creation of Quad, and North Korea’s continued missile tests. These factors had extensively impacted the discourse on extended deterrence. Therefore, to begin with, the paper aims to explore the origins of extended deterrence in the United States’ foreign policy. Secondly, it analyses how it has enforced it to protect its allies over the years and additionally examines the changes in the discourse during the Obama, Trump, and Biden administrations respectively. Finally, it examines the contemporary challenges the USA faces in implementing extended deterrence in the contemporary Indo-Pacific theatre.